Have you seen the teaser for that abomination of an Amazon series? Tolkien must be turning in his grave like a kebab on a spit. I'm genuinely worried watching the full trailer will give me a veritable aneurysm. Why does the American movie industry have to inject its divisive poison into every beloved story? And why did the Tolkien estate stand for this and sold them rights? Surely they can't be starved for money at this point.
I'd rather they'd have "cancelled" Tolkien retroactively for introducing a people of a dark complexion as the enemy in his universe. It'd still be less insufferable than their strokes of genius like African-American elves or the Five Wizards being retconned into women. By the way, since someone complained about all the complaining in this thread just a page ago … this isn't about "possessive fandom", or whatever the left calls it.
It's the disrespect shown to Tolkien that angers me so. They're basically saying the books he spent ten years on writing aren't good enough and that it doesn't matter what he came up with. Here's the right thing to do if you don't like a book: Don't read it. Don't turn it into a movie.
And if you can't enjoy a story for what it is because the protagonist doesn't share your colour of skin, I'm genuinely sorry for you.
There are two big issues what that situation, and they are more or less solving themselves.
Considering it takes place during the "Second Age" (around 3000 years iirc) creating new characters isn't really a problem.
Elves and dwarves with dark skin? One could go on a stretch and say "why not"? After all Japanese manga and animated movies have their fair share of dark-skinned elves, usually referred to as "dark-elves". But these elves being dark skinned goes beyond their skin being dark; in other word it is not just about skin pigmentation but something that goes deeper in their character and mentality.
Black dwarves though? Never heard of them, not even in medias where dwarves leave in places other than mountain halls and underground cities. I do remember some RPG (though I can't remember the names) that featured dwarves inhabiting hills (pretty much like Hobbits in fact). But in the end, none of them were black; and how can how have a melanin-rich skin when living in an environment deprived of sun light?
Maybe there were one or two in the movie Willow. Yes, I think there was at least one.
Problem is, races created by Tolkien were based on western and northern folklore and mythology. Not African, Indian, Asian, Arabic ones.
Another one is events and actions from characters that go against the canonicity. For instance, it appears that Galadriel will be portrayed as some kind of high-profile warrior climbing ice covered cliffs and going on Tomb Raider like quests.
Sure, it looks fun. But it's not canon. Didn't happen, for one, but mainly, it could not have happened to begin with.