- Joined
- Apr 25, 2019
- Messages
- 3,999
- Points
- 234
So … for weeks German farmers have protested against government plans to end diesel tax breaks which they say would put smaller farms out of business. The protests yielded some results, Berlin promised to exempt smaller farms and introduce pauses for struggling ones.
Yesterday, a 200-strong group of angry farmers waited for German economy minister Robert Habeck in a north sea port as he was returning by ferry from vacation on the Isle of Hooge. They prevented the ferry from landing. Habeck is a fool, but he did something smart and fair last night, I'll give him that: He asked the farmers to appoint a speaker with whom he could meet and listen to their grievances.
The farmers refused, instead trying to board the ferry by force. The police had to use pepper spray and the ferry had to depart for safety reasons. Obviously, further talks are well and truly off the table now.
In my mind, there's no real difference between activities such as this and the Extinction Rebellion blockades. (And in fairness to this otherwise useless administration, even though the coalition includes the Green Party they've given ER the same treatment: no negotiations or meetings until you start to obey the law.)
Even if you think it wasn't wrong for them to essentially jump the minister during the holidays and to put up such a threatening posture, you'll concede at the very least that it wasn't smart. The media paint them as right-wing insurrectionists now and the government (not without reason, I'm afraid) says they can't negotiate with people who try to coerce elected representatives.
I just don't get it – on both sides of the aisle. Why can't they see they're doing their respective causes a massive disservice?
Yesterday, a 200-strong group of angry farmers waited for German economy minister Robert Habeck in a north sea port as he was returning by ferry from vacation on the Isle of Hooge. They prevented the ferry from landing. Habeck is a fool, but he did something smart and fair last night, I'll give him that: He asked the farmers to appoint a speaker with whom he could meet and listen to their grievances.
The farmers refused, instead trying to board the ferry by force. The police had to use pepper spray and the ferry had to depart for safety reasons. Obviously, further talks are well and truly off the table now.
In my mind, there's no real difference between activities such as this and the Extinction Rebellion blockades. (And in fairness to this otherwise useless administration, even though the coalition includes the Green Party they've given ER the same treatment: no negotiations or meetings until you start to obey the law.)
Even if you think it wasn't wrong for them to essentially jump the minister during the holidays and to put up such a threatening posture, you'll concede at the very least that it wasn't smart. The media paint them as right-wing insurrectionists now and the government (not without reason, I'm afraid) says they can't negotiate with people who try to coerce elected representatives.
I just don't get it – on both sides of the aisle. Why can't they see they're doing their respective causes a massive disservice?