Book What are you reading?

"The Butchering Art: Joseph Lister's Quest to Transform the Grizzly Art of Victorian Medicine" by Lindsey Fitzharris. It describes 19th century surgery - horrifying stuff - and Joseph Lister's progress as a surgeon and scientist. He was raised a Quaker, and his father was a scientist who developed a particular lens for microscopes, and so was more interested in science than most other surgeons. He did a ton of work to discover why infections developed and killed so many of their patients. It's really interesting, and looking at it from a modern perspective hygiene and infection control seem so much like common sense that I want to yell at them "wash your hands!". The book describes surgeons using the same tools for multiple patients without washing them, and wearing gowns crusted stiff with dried blood and gore. Oh, and anaesthesia wasn't a thing. Imagine having your leg amputated while fully awake. As a pop history book it's written in a colloquial style, and the author takes some creative liberties, but it seems to be well researched with a cohesive narrative.
 
I read somewhere that theyd give you a swig of alcohol and a piece of wood to bite down on for amputation which was really just in prep for you inevitably passing out. I wonder when or if they figured to give patients an entire bottle of rum to drink before discovering anaesthesia
 
As I have studied again (I know, I did not skimp on my previous master's degree), now I am reading enough documents about research methods in history; For now, finishing reading the sixth chapter of the book "Colombia, a nation in spite of itself", which we have been commissioned to review and investigating about the Colombian civil wars before the creation of political parties o_O
 
@TheKiwi 's favourite author has the first book of a new trilogy out.

9780399593314.jpg
 
Such a negative Nancy...
 
I'm reading Going Clear by Lawrence Wright, the same book Gaz mentioned upthread. I'd had it on my to-read list for a while, but after Gaz's review I got it from the library. It is, to quote Gwen Stefani, "B-A-N-A-N-A-S". I knew their beliefs were odd, but I had no idea about the extent of the physical abuse. The fact that one person (first Hubbard, then David Miscavige) has such a strong hold over such a large organisation is insane. It's hard to believe that so many people can buy into the delusion. If Hubbard wasn't so charismatic he'd be remembered like Heinlein as an author of pulpy sci-fi, not the Messiah.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gaz
Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI, by David Grann. In the 19th century the Osage nation was moved from Kansas to what was is now Oklahoma, and in the early 20th century oil was discovered on that land. Their leader at the time was very savvy, and before the presence of the oil became widely known some of the Osage had become aware that the oil was there. They sent a lawyer to Congress to negotiate ownership of the land, and part of the contract was that the Osage would own anything in the ground. Congress at the time thought it was a nothing clause and agreed to it I think almost just to humour them. Joke's on them though because once oil was discovered the Osage became the world's wealthiest people, although maybe it was the Osage on whom the joke was, because racist-ass Congress decided that the Osage weren't allowed to manage their own money, and appointed guardians to manage it. If someone wanted to spend their money they had to ask their guardian, and they were only allowed to withdraw a certain amount of it at a time. There were politicians who actually spent their time poring over bank statements to learn what the Osage members were spending their money on. Obviously, there were white men who were stupid with money too, but they were allowed to make those mistakes.

Individual Osage members were being killed; there were something like 24 over a four year period, and also killed were white people who tried to advocate on their behalf. One man went to Washington to speak with politicians about investigating the murders and was murdered there, and a lawman / detective dispatched to investigate was also murdered (on a train). Eventually J. Edgar Hoover got the nascent FBI involved, although he was trying to hire people who were educated and au fait with modern investigative methods. He still had a handful of older, Wild West-style lawmen on the books, and so he sent one in to investigate, giving him the leeway to assemble a team. This guy became the public face of the investigation despite the safety risk, and he brought in an undercover team. One of them came into town as an insurance salesman and set up a shop selling real insurance policies while investigating. I haven't got much further than this, but it seems like a widespread conspiracy between very powerful people to bump off the richest of the Osage. The book is easy to read and very informative and engaging, I highly recommend it.
 
I'm reading Going Clear by Lawrence Wright, the same book Gaz mentioned upthread. I'd had it on my to-read list for a while, but after Gaz's review I got it from the library. It is, to quote Gwen Stefani, "B-A-N-A-N-A-S". I knew their beliefs were odd, but I had no idea about the extent of the physical abuse. The fact that one person (first Hubbard, then David Miscavige) has such a strong hold over such a large organisation is insane. It's hard to believe that so many people can buy into the delusion. If Hubbard wasn't so charismatic he'd be remembered like Heinlein as an author of pulpy sci-fi, not the Messiah.

It's staggering. Still haven't really wrapped my head around it.
 
I'm reading Going Clear by Lawrence Wright, the same book Gaz mentioned upthread. I'd had it on my to-read list for a while, but after Gaz's review I got it from the library. It is, to quote Gwen Stefani, "B-A-N-A-N-A-S". I knew their beliefs were odd, but I had no idea about the extent of the physical abuse. The fact that one person (first Hubbard, then David Miscavige) has such a strong hold over such a large organisation is insane. It's hard to believe that so many people can buy into the delusion. If Hubbard wasn't so charismatic he'd be remembered like Heinlein as an author of pulpy sci-fi, not the Messiah.

Having read what I have - an assuming no insder knowledge -, what do you think of Hubbard?

Fraudster, or did he believe the S**t he was shovelling? I honestly am unsure.
 
Best served Cold from Joe Abercrombie
A dark medieval fantasy novel (very few fantasy, a lot of dark) about a merc been betrayed by his former boss and looking for vengeance
Full of gore, derogatory sentences, blood and sex. Not Tolkien material at all, worth the read ....
 
Four Ball One Tracer. One of the Executive Outcomes commanders wrote it.
 
Just started "In Defence of History" by Sir Richard J. Evans. Basically this is a book about the history of History, on Historiography and the effects of Post-Modernism in this academic discipline.
 
Such a negative Nancy...

I put out a "John Birmingham book" this morning after my first coffee of the day. It was at least as well formed and legible as his best work.
 
Having read what I have - an assuming no insder knowledge -, what do you think of Hubbard?

Fraudster, or did he believe the S**t he was shovelling? I honestly am unsure.

I can't decide either. He had a lot of output when he was being paid to write fiction, and he lied A LOT to everyone about almost every aspect of his history. He obviously has a very good imagination, and he wanted people to admire him and follow him; he didn't seem to want to interact with people as their peers, he wanted to be on a pedestal. So, in answer to your question, I don't know. When he was conceiving of the bulk of Scientology's mythology / creation story he was very isolated, on a boat at sea with a small group of people. It's easy to lose perspective in a situation like that. I honestly wouldn't be surprised either way.


I just finished reading The Nickel Boys, by Colson Whitehead. It's a look at how ideals and institutions clash, and I recommend it if you never want to be happy again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gaz
An Ember in the Ashes by Sabaa Tahir. It's a Young Adult fantasy novel set in a world that kind of resembles a Roman-occupied vaguely Middle Eastern region. The indigenous people are banned from learning and reduced to low level service occupations and are oppressed by a militaristic regime. A local girl joins the resistance after her brother is arrested and infiltrates a military academy, and there's a student in the military academy who wants to defect, so they join forces to, I guess take down the empire? Being a YA novel there's an awkward love quadrangle shoe-horned in, but it's pretty obvious what's going to happen. It was pretty entertaining, and I'm going to keep reading the sequels, maybe, I've just had a look at it's up to book 3 and a fourth book has been announced. I still have Wheel of Time PTSD, I'm not committing to another long-running series.

I'm currently reading The Foreign Correspondent by Alan Furst. It's set mostly in France in 1939, and the main character is a journalist for Reuters. He's an Italian expat living in Paris who also contributes to an anti-fascist newspaper that various resistance members circulate in Italy. He attracts attention from British and French intelligence services, and becomes drawn into espionage. It's very well written, I'm really loving it, but it is very slow and taking me a long time to read.
 
I have finished reading my second book for masters, it is about the relations between the military and civilians from the beginning of the struggle for the independence of Colombia until the birth of their political parties, very interesting! o_O
 
Finally managed to finish Lovecraft.

His writing style is clearly inspired by Edgar Alan Poe, though absolutely not as talented to the point that the stories can often be tedious to read.

His universe is fascinating though. As well as what has been built around it.
 
^Lovecrafts writing is certainly somewhat limited but as you said, the universe he created is something else... otherwoldly *chuckles malignantly while gazing at the Trapezoedron*

Currently reading the Sharpe series by Bernard Cornwell after finishing bingewatching the Hornblower movies (which can also be found on Youtube in very decent quality). Not too fond of the German translation here and there but it´ll do.
I did like the bits of the Sharpe movies with Sean Bean I saw some years ago as well - the differences, especially in scale of the battles and the setting in general compared to the novels are notable, still a very enjoayble series to watch.

Are there any authors/novels you guys would recommend who set their novels in a similar time frame - Napoleonic Wars, Age of Sail in general and so forth?
 
^Lovecrafts writing is certainly somewhat limited but as you said, the universe he created is something else... otherwoldly *chuckles malignantly while gazing at the Trapezoedron*

Currently reading the Sharpe series by Bernard Cornwell after finishing bingewatching the Hornblower movies (which can also be found on Youtube in very decent quality). Not too fond of the German translation here and there but it´ll do.
I did like the bits of the Sharpe movies with Sean Bean I saw some years ago as well - the differences, especially in scale of the battles and the setting in general compared to the novels are notable, still a very enjoayble series to watch.

Are there any authors/novels you guys would recommend who set their novels in a similar time frame - Napoleonic Wars, Age of Sail in general and so forth?
For the age of sail novels, try those by Julian Stockwin, excellent stuff!
 
Back
Top