On this day July 20 plot

muck

Mi Field Marshall
MI.Net Member
TheMess.Net
Joined
Apr 25, 2019
Messages
3,914
Points
234
Germany
Eighty years ago today, the last and most promising plot of the German resistance to depose Adolf Hitler fails when a freak chance saves the dictator's life. The regime retaliates with death sentences for some 200 of the conspirators. Some 5.000 people end up in concentration camps.
 
Amongst them the Desert Fox, Erwin Rommel who was eventually forced to commit suicide in fear of reprisal against his relatives in Germany.

Considering the Third Reich tyranny, whether that was Sophie Scholl or other members of the German resistance, one needed titanium cojones to try and overthrow them. Respect.
 
Amongst them the Desert Fox, Erwin Rommel who was eventually forced to commit suicide in fear of reprisal against his relatives in Germany.

Considering the Third Reich tyranny, whether that was Sophie Scholl or other members of the German resistance, one needed titanium cojones to try and overthrow them. Respect.
Yes.

The regime made a terrible example of the chief conspirators who'd survived the 20th of July*. The majority of them were not shot or guillotined, but hanged. And not from a long-drop noose, mind you, but from a piano string.

*) Masterminds Colonels Graf von Stauffenberg, Mertz von Quirnheim and General Olbricht, as well as Stauffenberg's aide Lieutenant von Haeften, were summarily executed immediatedly after the plot's discovery by orders of General Fromm, commanding general of the reserve army, who likely sought to hide his having looked the other way.

The fourth ringleader, General von Tresckow, wisely committed suicide upon hearing the news that Hitler had survived.

Tresckow in particular should be remembered as one of history's tragic heroes. There's some evidence that earlier in the war, he'd passed on orders sanctioning massacres of partisans in Belarus (though it's questionable if his refusal had lead to a different outcome). On the other hand, von Tresckow was a fervent anti-Nazi and tried to kill Hitler three times, only to be thwarted by some stupid chance each time.

The biographies of the conspirators are fascinating to me. A few of them were opportunists and war criminals (like Graf von Helldorf, Berlin's chief of police). But others, much like Stauffenberg himself, were conservatives and religious Christians who grew a conscience when it mattered most.

However, Rommel is a very strange case. It seems that he only ever cared about being a captain of war, and that he was politically naive to the highest of levels. There's evidence that Rommel in 1943 suggested to Hitler that a Jew should be appointed NSDAP gauleiter, so as to improve Germany's image in the world. Hitler is said to replied: "My dear Rommel, you don't get it, do you."
 
Killing Hitler wouldn't have made any difference, not in 1944 nor in 1934. Even a stray shell on the Western Front wouldn't have changed history that much.

He didn't come up with this stuff, he used sentiments already there and exploited them.
-The final solution was design-by-committee;
-The "stab in the back" was widespread sentiment;
-Europe has been anti-semetic since at least the High Medieval Period;
-Calls for vengeance after a lost war are as old as time itself;
-No money = mo problemz = radical change NOW!.

If not Hitler it would have been someone else, in 1944 certainly the SS because the Heer imo was not homogenous enough to carry out a successful coup.

People deranged enough to use chemical weapons against cities, even their own if they didn't fight to the death to the new Führer's liking.

Hitler has been made bigger than he was to give every individual cog that made up the German state a scapegoat for their own actions.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top